cast away

Comments

What's funny is that I own eight of these albums. Two of the ones that I don't own are at least by people (or about people) I've heard of. And then there's that one I've never even heard of. Who is the Dirty Three?
They're a terrible, depressing band of ex-convicts.
I assume Daby is referring to the Dirty Three as ex-convicts because they're Australian. Not sure what he means by terrible or depressing though, as they are neither. Once again he is demonstrating for all to see his completely lack of appreciating for anything approaching subtlety or complexity in music.
Yeah, I don't know where he got the depressing, maybe from that wikipedia page you linked to:
Dirty Three have gradually shifted their focus towards a slower, arguably more melancholic, style of playing.
Slow doesn't necessarily mean depressing. But it is instrumental music, so people who are unable to think for themselves about how they feel about the music they listen to might get a little confused.
Music without words is pointless.
You Know You Are A Hipster D-bag When:

You include In The Aeroplane Over The Sea in your list of top albums.
Them's fighting words. What's wrong with that record?
Zzzz....
You really need to give it another shot, it might be a lot of things, but boring it isn't.
You're pointless.

And Jason is wrong.
The Dirty Three suck balls.

And Jason is wrong.
You suck balls.

And Jason is wrong.
Do three wrongs make a right?

That's an inspired choice to take a tribute to Nebraska over Nebraska itself. Personally, I'd have a hard time taking a disc that featured Ben Harper. Just a personal thing, though.

I'm with you on the Beulah and Whiskeytown selections.

The tribute record is a more pleasant (potentially) everyday listening experience. And while there is no excuse for Ben Harper's existence, the Dar Williams cover of "Highway Patrolman" gives me chills every time. Plus, there's that bonus track of John R. Cash singing "I'm On Fire."

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in